Skip to content

Best bars in Bay Shore

Vegetarian / Vegan Restaurant
$$
“Top notch organically prepared gourmet with a great selection of traditional and vegan cuisine.”
3 locals recommend
Bar
“Great place in Bay Shore with nice atmosphere, good food and often live music. Nice patio bar out back”
1 local recommends
Restaurant
$$
Bar
“Great, nicely prepared Tex/Mex. Good value with a great selection of Tequilas ”
1 local recommends
Bar
“A Long Island franchise but Bay Shore's is the best. Good food. Lots of big screen TV's for sports viewing. Patio bar out back. Cheerful, noisy place ( you won't be able to hear a thing any one is saying, including your waitress : ) with a great late night energy. ( if that's what you prefer! )”
1 local recommends
Bar
“Our new favorite place! Cozy. Right by Bay Shore Marina. The food was excellent. The atmosphere is great. The waitress was nice her name was Mary . We would definitely come back for the seafood hummus with the homemade pitas which were delicious! Lobster Macaroni and Cheese with chunks of real lobster! This is a great little place. They have live music on Friday and Saturday evening! Prices are very reasonable, and service is great in a great atmosphere. Who could ask for more?”
1 local recommends
Asian Restaurant
$$
“Great Sushi and Hibachi Japanese that reviles over priced NoBu in NYC. The newest of three Sushi restaurants here. But definitely the one to try first!”
1 local recommends
Bar
“What once was the historic "Half Penny" Pub, now owned by the same owners of TJ Finley's has become even richer. It's like stepping in to an authentic Irish pub in Dublin. Now serving late night food. Get a gourmet breakfast sandwich at 1:00 am after having a few Guinness's. Best way to prevent a hangover!”
1 local recommends
Restaurant
$$