Skip to content
Entire apartment

The Case-Jennings House on Shelter Island

Florence A User Profile
Florence A

The Case-Jennings House on Shelter Island

4 guests
2 bedrooms
2 beds
1 bath
4 guests
2 bedrooms
2 beds
1 bath
HOME HIGHLIGHTS
Quick responses16 recent guests said this host responded quickly.
Self check-inEasily check yourself in with the keypad.
Florence A is a SuperhostSuperhosts are experienced, highly rated hosts who are committed to providing great stays for guests.

The Case-Jennings House is a beautiful Shelter Island gem. "Anna's Cottage" was built in 1847 and stands proudly as one of the island's oldest homes.
In the same family for four generations, this two-bedroom treasure was newly renovated and restored in 2017. It is dressed in contemporary farmhouse decor and located within one mile of restaurants, shops, the beach, ferry and a golf course. This immaculate and comfortable space is ready to welcome you to the simpler way of Shelter Island life.

Amenities

Kitchen
Wifi
Free parking on premises
Indoor fireplace
Cable TV
Washer

Sleeping arrangements

Bedroom 1
1 queen bed
Bedroom 2
1 queen bed

House Rules

No smoking
No pets
No parties or events
Check-in time is 3PM - 12AM (midnight)
Self check-in with keypad

Availability

61 Reviews

Accuracy
Communication
Cleanliness
Location
Check-in
Value
Jessica User Profile
Jessica
August 2018
The host canceled this reservation 30 days before arrival. This is an automated posting.
Nicole User Profile
Nicole
August 2018
Perfect cottage on Shelter Island! Sparkling clean and easy communication. Great location for walking, biking, or driving. We would stay again!
Florence A User Profile
Response from Florence A:
Nicole and her guest will always be welcome to return to "Anna's Cottage". They were quiet, considerate, respectful, easy to communicate with, tidy and clean, leaving the house spotless! I highly recommend Nicole and her guest and would welcome them again without hesitation. Thank you for being Super Guests! Florence
August 2018
Andrew User Profile
Andrew
August 2018
We arrived Friday evening, met Florence, (the cottage was recently renovated and impeccably clean),we did not have dinner plans for Friday so Florence recommended the Pridwin, we dined there, beautiful views, the tuna crudo was excellent along with the smoked duck and sausage. (…
Florence A User Profile
Response from Florence A:
Meeting and welcoming Andrew, Hong and their beautiful well behaved children to my grandparent's home and Shelter Island was a pleasure. The were friendly, considerate, thoughtful, easy to communicate with, tidy and super clean; the house was spotless! I highly recommend Andrew and his family and would welcome them again without hesitation. Thank you for being Super Guests! Florence
August 2018
Lauren User Profile
Lauren
August 2018
Lovely, clean and well-decorated home in great location. Florence is a fantastic host and makes every effort to ensure your stay is a positive one. Hope to come back soon!
Florence A User Profile
Response from Florence A:
It was such a pleasure meeting and welcoming Lauren and her family to my grandparent's home and Shelter Island. Communication was easy throughout booking, arrival and departure. Aside from being friendly, respectful, considerate and quiet, they were tidy and clean, leaving the house in perfect order. I highly recommend Lauren and her family and would welcome them again without hesitation. Thank you for being Super Guests! Florence
August 2018
Janice User Profile
Janice
July 2018
We've just returned from our weekend stay at Florence's cottage. Everything was clean, comfortable, and enjoyable. Florence responded quickly to any questions we had and was able to get us into the cottage before check-in time and suggest restaurants in the area. We had a fantast…
Florence A User Profile
Response from Florence A:
Welcoming Janice and Ben was such a pleasure! We had easy communication throughout the booking, arrival and departure. They were respectful, considerate, quiet, tidy and clean. The house was left in perfect order. I highly recommend Janice and Ben and would welcome them again without hesitation. Thank you for being Super Guests! Florence
July 2018
Christopher User Profile
Christopher
July 2018
Great place conveniently located to beaches. We had a great time. Florence contacted us ahead of time and asked if we would like a pack and play crib set up for our little one, such a nice touch - and saved us from packing ours! Thanks again!
Florence A User Profile
Response from Florence A:
It was pleasure meeting and welcoming Christopher, Lauren and their beautiful well behaved children to my grandparent's home. They were friendly, considerate, respectful, quiet, easy to communicate with, tidy and clean. I was pleasantly surprised finding the house spotless! Thank you for being Super Guests! You are always welcome to return! Florence
July 2018
Melody User Profile
Melody
July 2018
Florence is an excellent host. Responsive and helpful. Came over to make sure I got settled in as soon as I let her know I was on my way. Lovely space. Well located. Enjoy!!
Florence A User Profile
Response from Florence A:
Melody was a wonderful guest. She was friendly, respectful, considerate, thoughtful, quiet, easy to communicate with, tidy and clean. I highly recommend Melody and would welcome her again without hesitation! Thank you for being a Super Guests! Florence
July 2018

Hosted by Florence A

Shelter Island Heights, New York, United StatesJoined in May 2017
Florence A User Profile
61 Reviews
Florence A is a SuperhostSuperhosts are experienced, highly rated hosts who are committed to providing great stays for guests.
Response rate: 100%
Response time: within an hour
Always communicate through AirbnbTo protect your payment, never transfer money or communicate outside of the Airbnb website or app.

The neighborhood

Press the down arrow key to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.

Check In

Press the down arrow key to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.

Check Out
You won’t be charged yet

Similar listings