The Case-Jennings House is a beautiful Shelter Island gem. "Anna's Cottage" was built in 1847 and stands proudly as one of the island's oldest homes.
In the same family for four generations, this two-bedroom treasure was newly renovated and restored in 2017. It is dressed in contemporary farmhouse decor and located within one mile of restaurants, shops, the beach, ferry and a golf course. This immaculate and comfortable space is ready to welcome you to the simpler way of Shelter Island life.
Free parking on premises