Skip to content
Poolfire pit and outdoor dining
Save this listing.
Entire house

Private home with pool and tennis

Sally User Profile

Private home with pool and tennis

Entire house
16+ guests4 bedrooms18 beds5.5 baths
16+ guests
4 bedrooms
18 beds
5.5 baths
Self check-in
Easily check yourself in with the lockbox.

Relaxed casual space for gatherings with pool, tennis court, bocce court, basketball. Common space seating for 10+ in dining and living room.


Hot tub
Free parking on premises
Indoor fireplace

Sleeping arrangements

Bedroom 1
1 double bed, 2 single beds
Bedroom 2
1 double bed, 2 single beds
Bedroom 3
1 queen bed, 2 single beds
Bedroom 4
1 queen bed, 3 single beds
Common spaces
5 single beds

House Rules

No smoking, parties, or events
Pets are allowed
Check-in is anytime after 4PM and check out by 12PM (noon)
Self check-in with lockbox


Well-lit path to entrance


11 Reviews

Teresa M User Profile
Teresa M
July 2018
Sally's house was an amazing find for our large group of 16 adults. The house easily accommodated everyone with plenty of beds and bathrooms. The large kitchen, common space and beautiful pool were wonderful for lounging. Sally's home had all the comfort of home. I would note th…
Stephen User Profile
May 2018
Great location and amenities!
Laurence User Profile
April 2018
The host canceled this reservation 121 days before arrival. This is an automated posting.
Bradley User Profile
January 2018
Dear Airbnb, The house itself serves its purpose for a big group. It is cozy, with a big living room and a couple of big bedrooms. The kitchen is a really nice communal place to cook. I can't speak to the pool because we visited in the winter, but it looks nice. However, there…
Sally User Profile
Response from Sally:
Over The Course Of 17 Years Of Hosting, Over 30 Reviews (Here And Elsewhere) Have Given Me 4.5 Stars. Brad’s Primary Complaint Is Hot Tub Didn’t Work. However The Breakdown Was Caused By Brad And I Am Making A Claim On The Security Deposit. So To Offset That, He Is Coming Up With A Litany Of Complaints To Justify Asking For 50% Of His Money Back.(Equal To The Amount Of The Security). That Weekend The Temperature Reached down to the single digits the coldest in decades. As A Result Pipes All Over The Northeast Froze. Too Many People (8 or more) Went In The Perfectly Working Tub which was At 102 Degrees Friday Evening (Per The Information Provided By Another Guest At The House) For An Hour And Displaced Enough Water To Leave The Water Level Below The Filter Line, Which Caused The Circulation Pump To Stop Running. The Guests Say That The Jets Stopped While They Were In The Tub. However, They Didn’t Contact Me Until The Next Day. By That Time, After 12 Hours Without Water Going Through The Pump And Lines, The Equipment Froze. I Didn’t Think I Had To Point Out Not To Put More People In The Tub Than There Were Seats. I Have A Jacuzzi Bathtub As Well Whose Pipes Froze. I Texted To Give An Instruction The First Evening To try to Prevent This From Happening. Because It Wasn’t understood or done, they did freeze And My Husband Went Over Saturday, (30 Minutes After Being Called), To Take Care Of It. He Did Fix The Bathtub and Spent All Day In The Freezing Cold Trying To Fix The Hot Tub The short of it: hot tub - renter’s fault. I’m very sorry it happened and I know it was his main source of enjoyment but I provided a working hot tub as he can attest to. jacuzzi bath - fixed upon phone call garbage bags - offered substitute ice machine - provided ice all other complaints are fictional Here Is My Response To All His Other Complaints. To Begin With, Every Text And Phone Call Was Returned Within 30 Minutes, This house has 6 Bedrooms, 6 Baths And 18 Beds, It Clearly Is Set Up For 16 Guests. The Heat Worked Perfectly Upon Arrival And Departure. The Tenants Didn’t Contact Me About Heat Complaints During Their Stay (Perhaps Because There Was No Actual Problem). They Had A Fire Going The Entire Time They Were There. Keeping A Fire Going Actually Removes Heat From The Room. Fires Are For Show, Not For Heat, Unless You Have A Blower. The Dishwasher And Garbage Disposal Worked Perfectly Both Before And After His Stay. Brad Clogged The Disposal And Didn’t Bother To Call To Ask Where The Reset Button Was. The Ice Machine Was Broken, Which I Told Him In Advance And Provided A Full Icemaker Of Ice Plus An Entire Bag Which Was The Equivalent Of 2 Days Worth Of Ice For His 3 Day Stay. No Garbage Bags: The Cleaning Women Used The Last Garbage Bag and I told him I had other small bags To Use If They Didn’t Want To Take A “5” (Not 30) Minute Trip Into Sag Harbor. Regarding Provisions, I Provide An Entire Refrigerator Door Of Condiments For Guest Use As Well As All Cleaners, Propane Gas For Bbq, Etc. I Happen To Know That Their Shopping Hadn’t Been Done Yet Because The Girls Who Showed Up early Asked Me Where To Go To Shop. As for his story about arrival- Brad Wasn’t There And Seems To Be Confused About Timing. I Told him he Could Come Anytime After 4pm but That I Had To Leave By 5 (There Are Instructions For Entry). The First 2 Guests Arrived At 345 While I Was Out And I Texted Them To Ring The Doorbell And The Cleaning Ladies Would Let Them In. I Gave Them A Tour When I Returned At 4 And Then I Left.
January 2018
Cici User Profile
August 2017
great for group
Sally User Profile
Response from Sally:
Your group was very respectful, thank-you.
August 2017
Raquel User Profile
July 2017
A beautiful home and wonderful hosts. Everything explained perfectly upon arrival. Highly recommend!
Zachary User Profile
July 2017
The house was awesome and Sally was a great host, providing all the details up front and being super responsive on text throughout the weekend. The pool was perfect for the 90+ degree days and the tennis courts, basketball hoop and hot tub kept us all entertained all weekend. Th…

Hosted by Sally

Wainscott, New York, United StatesJoined in September 2012
Sally User Profile
33 Reviews
family of 4
Sally supports the Living Wage Pledge
People who clean this host’s listing are paid a living wage. Learn more
Languages: English, Español
Always communicate through AirbnbTo protect your payment, never transfer money or communicate outside of the Airbnb website or app.

The neighborhood

Things to do near this home