Entire home/apt
6 Guests
3 Bedrooms
5 Beds

Request to Book

Per Night
Per Month

This property is unavailable.

When are you traveling?
Enter dates for accurate prices and availability.

This is a rare find.
Jeffrey's place is usually booked.
Love this place? Book soon!
Chances are...
Jeffrey's place will get booked for these dates.
Chances are...
Jeffrey's place will get booked for these dates.
Reserve for disaster relief
Jeffrey has waived the cost of staying here for people displaced by
Strict Cancellation
50% refund until one week before arrival, except service fees.
Report this listing
You have reported this listing. Undo?

About this listing

A cottage on five private wooded acres. The cottage sits on top of the hill, with a private road leading to several hundred feet of private waterfront on Second Creek, just at it enters Great Sodus Bay.

Contact Host

We're down this road about a mile through field and woods.  Almost there.

We're down this road about a mile through field and woods. Almost there.

The Space
Bathrooms: 1.5
Bedrooms: 3
Beds: 5
Check In: 3:00 PM
Check Out: 11:00 AM
Room type: Entire home/apt


Extra people: No Charge
Cleaning Fee: $50
Weekly discount: 5%
Cancellation: Flexible


The Space

Get away from it all at this comfortable cottage in the woods and with access to its own waterfront area.

Our place is on Great Sodus Bay, a bay off Lake Ontario some 40 miles east of Rochester and 25 miles north of the Finger Lakes Region. It is on one of the few relatively undeveloped areas of the Bay, with newly-established conservation land all around. It is a few minutes to the village of Sodus Point, with restaurants, a historic lighthouse and beaches on the bay and Lake Ontario.

While a lot of waterfront property on the bay and the Finger Lakes is fairly well-developed, we are fortunate to have five completely private acres with several hundred feet of waterfront. The waterfront is on Second Creek, which opens just past our property onto the bay.

Our place has two floors. You enter on the main living floor, which has cathedral ceilings in finished pine, a huge stone fireplace and sliding glass doors to a back deck on two sides of the house. There are two other bedrooms on the main floor, along with a completely new kitchen (as of July 2014) and full bathroom.

Downstairs is another large living area.. The Boat Bar is there, too, an actual wooden craft set up as a bar with nautical charts all around. There's another bedroom on this floor, too. Since the house is built on a slope, you exit from this lower floor to the back of the house.

The house is set on the top of the ridge, so the deck looks down the hillside to the water. We have our own road leading down through the property to the water. At the bottom of the hill, there is a small shed set up to sleep two in a rustic fashion, though there's no water or electricity at the bottom of the hill.

As you'll see from the pictures, our place is on a creek, right at the point the creek opens to the bay. The water is shallow with some weeds, so most people won't want to swim here (though our daughters have jumped in from time to time). And, being shallow, we haven't tried to put a boat in, although we have kept a jet ski there successfully, and have used it to get out into the bay.

We have several benches interspersed at various points along the road and paths to create little "places" for reading or contemplation (see pictures).

Also, we have several kayaks with which you can turn right and go directly out onto the bay. Or you can turn left and explore the wonderful Second Creek, a meandering maze of water and wildlife. We've seen foxes, beaver, deer and all manner of water birds.

The area around the house has just been acquired by a nature conservancy. So the creek and the area around it is protected. Down the street, where the road to the cottage turns in, is historic Alasa Farms, originally a Shaker compound and now preserved as part of the conservancy agreement for large animal shelter, farming and historic programs.

Access to the house is down an almost mile long gravel road from Alasa Farms through fields and woods. Past our place, along the bay, there are another handful of cottages.

Sodus Bay itself is great for swimming, boating, fishing, etc. A short drive into town (Sodus Point) brings you to swimming beaches both on the bay and on Lake Ontario as well as restaurants, bars and things to do.


You want to know what might be missing in this glowing account? Nothing works for everybody so here are some other things about the place you should read about to make sure it is for you.

Please note that as stated above we are on a shallow creek and it's not for swimmers. The house is on the top of the hill looking down through trees through the water, which is visible through several "windows" though the trees. But the cottage itself is not "on the water". We just installed a brand new kitchen (including a dishwasher) but overall, the place gives off a homey, not a showoff, vibe. This ain't the Hamptons, it's our home, and we use it too. The bed linens and towels will all be fresh and clean, but they are family style, not hotel style. We do not have a washer-dryer (laundromats a few minutes drive if you need one). And we do not have wi-fi, an internet connection or, frankly, any good over the air TV reception. We do have a large screen TV and DVD player for your media needs, and the area has very good cell reception from AT&T and spotty cell reception from T-Mobile.

I reiterate these caveats here since all potential renters should have a full picture of the place to make sure it is a good fit. If you are thinking this is a high end palace, or a fake "retreat" complete with internet and cable, think again. It is a real retreat from all that.

Room type: Entire home/apt
Bed type: Real Bed
Accommodates: 6 or more depending on use of beds and shed
Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 1.5
Extra people: No Charge
Minimum Stay: 7 nights
Weekly Price: $1600 /week
Monthly Price: $4500 /month
Cleaning Fee: $50
Country: United States
City: Sodus
Size: 2000 ft2 (186 m2)
Cancellation: Flexible

Other Things to Note

Since we are set up for weekly rentals or longer, we prefer if you bring your own bed linens and towels. However, we have a full set of sheets and both bath and beach towels at the cottage. These are nothing fancy--just what we use--but in a pinch, say if you don't have king sheets, you should feel free to use what is in the place.

+ More

7 nights minimum stay


2 Reviews

This host has 21 reviews for other properties.

View Other Reviews

About the Host, Jeffrey

Newton, Massachusetts, United States
Member since November 2011


Explore other options in and around Sodus